Below are three famous paintings, but I’ve photoshopped out the trees. You get a point for naming the artist, and two further points if you know the name of the painting.
Answers at the bottom. Click image to see the original.
[This project came about as an attempt to visually represent "loss". It's one of the themes that I've been working on with the artist Alice Ladenburg. It is relatively easy to represent the importance of something that is present, but how do you capture or express the importance of something like deforestation that is all about the absence of something? It is not easy to focus a viewer's attention on something that is not there! ]
1)
2)
3)
.
.
.
.
If you like these, let me know and I will do some others.
The answers are:
1) Constable’s “The Haywain”.
2) Seurat’s “Sunday afternoon on the Island of Grande Jatte”.
3) Van Gogh’s “Olive Trees with Yellow Sky and Sun”.
I smiled because both the Haywain and Sunday afternoon looked ‘acceptable’ to my eyes – in other words my view has already been ‘tainted’ by the landscapes I am increasingly exposed to. Only relative to the originals do you gain a sense of the unacceptable.
But Van Gogh’s ‘Ground preparation for the Thre Gorges Dam with Yellow Sky and Sun’ really does it for me.
William
Posted by william mackaness | January 8, 2013, 12:39 pmThanks William. I will take it as a compliment on my forgery skills that the two paintings looked acceptable!
Posted by fortiain | January 8, 2013, 12:46 pmYour photoshopping skills are to be commended! I agree with William – they looked okay (partly because the distant trees give the suggestion of a wooded landscape), until you see the originals in all their rich and verdant glory! Then the tree-less foregrounds look hopelessly bland. Very thought provoking!
Posted by Margaret Clift (@CollectiveMarg) | January 8, 2013, 1:44 pmI am impressed by your photoshop skills! I recognised Seurat’s “Sunday afternoon on the Island of Grande Jatte”, and thought it quite bare without the trees. The one that really brings it home is the last one by Van Gogh. Very bleak looking without the trees. I like this idea, it’s fun.
Posted by Emily Woollen | January 10, 2013, 6:32 pm6 points… (I gave myself one point for knowing that Seurat’s painting started with “Sunday Afternoon”. I didn’t know the title of the Van Gogh though.)
Posted by Chris Lang | January 13, 2013, 5:32 amMarina Galperina has made animated GIFs from these treeless-masters. v cool. http://animalnewyork.com/2013/seurat-sans-all-the-trees/
Posted by fortiain | January 14, 2013, 8:29 pmWow, I am impressed by your image processing skills ! I like that you did not just remove the trees but chop them off and perfectly reconstructed the missing parts (which seems most difficult for the Constable), very illustrative… Removal (reconstruction) of ambiguities, scalopping, gap filling would be ‘kindergarden’ for you
Posted by Felicitas von Poncet | January 14, 2013, 8:46 pmGenial!!!
Posted by Lucila | January 16, 2013, 2:04 pmJust been pointed to some great works by Bence Hajdu who has done something similar — except he has removed all the people from some great works of art. Check it out on Behance:
http://www.behance.net/gallery/abandoned-paintings/5555192
Posted by fortiain | January 16, 2013, 10:52 pm